The Tides of Transition

The Tides of Transition

A Historical Evolution of Fishing in Niagara-on-the-Lake

Ethan Carelse-Turner

Niagara - 2024

The history of fishing in Niagara-on-the-Lake is an important part of Niagara Region\'s history, which links early Indigenous nations\' traditions to modern fishing cultures. This essay will explore the history of fishing practices at Niagara, beginning with early Indigenous peoples methods and cultural practices and expanding into the evolution of fishing practices today. By examining the history of fishing techniques, methods, and influences on the Niagara Region, one may acquire significant insights into the evolution of Niagara-on-the-Lake.

To understand the evolution of fishing in Niagara-on-the-Lake, we must first investigate the fishing methods of the region\'s early Indigenous communities. These cultures, which were closely linked to the land and its resources, devised amazing fishing methods and tactics. The historical setting reveals a complex web of fishing practices, where Indigenous cultures created implements out of natural materials such as bone, wood, and stone that demonstrated a profound grasp of the surrounding environment.1 Fishing activities in early Indigenous cultures were more than just functional, they were deeply rooted in the tribes\' cultural fabric. Fishing provided a steady supply of protein and nutrients to these cultures. However, fishing was more than just a means of subsistence. It was also a symbolic and ceremonial activity, with techniques varied according to each Indigenous group\'s beliefs and customs.2 The complicated ceremonial and spiritual connections involved with fishing illustrated how these activities reflected Indigenous cultures\' close affinity with the aquatic environments that supported them.

The fishing tools used by early Indigenous Peoples were as varied as the regions they inhabited. Nets, traps, and hooks made from locally available materials were used with impressive creativity. The Indigenous peoples residing in what is now the town of Niagara-on-the-Lake employed many fishing implements and methods to utilize the abundant supplies found in the nearby rivers. Fish were captured by carefully constructed nets made of plant fibers or animal sinew that were placed in rivers, lakes, and coastal locations.3 In addition to this technique, natural materials such as branches, boulders, and woven baskets were used to build fish traps and weirs. Fish were carefully funneled into enclosed areas by these devices, making collecting them easier. Furthermore, bigger species like muskellunge and sturgeon were the target of specialized fishing spears and harpoons, which were frequently furnished with barbs or points.4 Indigenous groups were able to sustainably get a wide variety of fish because to this multidimensional approach to fishing, guaranteeing a crucial food supply and promoting commerce and cultural traditions within the region.

As time progressed these tools later evolved into more advanced practices that better helped sustain large groups. For example, the use of weirs and fish wheels in riverine habitats demonstrated a grasp of fish behavior and migration patterns, allowing these groups to gather fish more effectively during certain seasons.5 Certain Indigenous cultures displayed a thorough understanding of fish behavior and migratory patterns while studying riverine settings. The use of weirs, and cleverly designed obstacles made of rocks or wooden posts, demonstrated a keen awareness of the aquatic habitat. Weirs were intentionally placed in rivers to act as controlled channels, guiding fish migration and allowing for more efficient collection during various seasons. This strategy not only highlighted Indigenous understandings of the natural patterns of salmon migration but also displayed their ability to collaborate with the environment to maintain a sustainable and predictable food supply. 6 Figure 1 depicts a fishing weir.7 In addition to weirs, some Indigenous groups employed fish wheels, a mechanical apparatus designed to exploit the movement of water currents to catch fish. Positioned in river systems, these devices harnessed the energy of flowing water to turn wheels, which in turn, lifted fish from the water into waiting nets. The implementation of fish wheels highlighted an innovative approach to fishing, capitalizing on the dynamics of the local environment to enhance the efficiency of the harvest.8 Figure 2 depicts a fishing wheel.9

Figure 1: Example of a fishing weir used by Indigenous peoples to better control the flow and direction of the fish they caught.

Figure 2: An Indigenous fish wheel used as a tool to help gather fish from rivers and streams

Furthermore, the cultural and social significance of fishing went beyond its practical features. Fishing became essential to Indigenous cultural identity, inspiring art, storytelling, and information transfer from generation to generation. Specifically, salmon was among the most popular fish spices to be recognized and consumed most by Indigenous Peoples around Niagara-on-the-Lake. For Indigenous peoples of Niagara-on-the-Lake, salmon was deeply significant in terms of both ceremonial respect and cultural identification. The entrance of salmon during spawning season was welcomed with elaborate rituals that honored the mutual dependence of nature and humans, a tradition deeply ingrained in their spiritual beliefs.10 These customs promoted a deep appreciation for the environment while simultaneously honoring the land\'s wealth. Furthermore, salmon had a significant role in the intricate web of Indigenous oral traditions. Salmon represented spiritual balance and cultural continuity and went beyond simple nourishment to become a symbolic cornerstone of Indigenous existence in Niagara-on-the-Lake.11 Traditional ecological knowledge, which included an understanding of fish behavior, changes in the seasons, and sustainable harvesting strategies, was the foundation communities. Many Indigenous cultures saw fishing as a symbiotic connection with the environment, reflecting their great respect for nature and humanity\'s interconnectivity.

Before the massive expansion of the fishing industry in Canada early French European settlers played crucial roles in the expansion of the fishing industry in Niagara-on-the-Lake through exploration, settlement, trade, technological advancements, and cultural influence. These activities laid the foundation for the fishing industry in the region but could not have been possible without the groundwork and knowledge shared with them by Indigenous Peoples. In Niagara-on-the-Lake, trade and interaction between Indigenous peoples and European colonial settlers was essential. Mutual gain and cultural understanding were enhanced by this encounter.12 Furthermore, Indigenous knowledge of the area, particularly hunting and fishing methods, was very helpful to European settlers in navigating and making the most of the resources in the area. In exchange, settlers expanded the material culture and economic prospects of Indigenous people by bringing new trading routes and technology.13 Over the colonial era, both communities were able to survive and adapt because to this mutually beneficial exchange of goods and information.

The history of fishing and fisheries in Canada has a vast background that ties together the country\'s economic, cultural, and environmental growth. With a focus on the rise of commercial fisheries, coastal history demonstrated what fueled the growth of fishing operations in Canada, Commercial fisheries in Canada began with the arrival of European immigrants, whose fishing tactics were influenced by centuries-old marine traditions. Traditional fishing gear such as longlines, handlines, and traps were eventually replaced by more advanced technology such as schooners and steam-powered vessels.14 Such revolutions in fishing practices constituted a watershed moment, allowing fishermen to go into deeper seas and exploit a broader range of fish species, profoundly changing the volume and intensity of fishing activity. The steam powered vessels were introduced into the fishing industry during the 1860's and within 10 years the average catches of cod alone increased by almost 100,000 tons going from about 200,000 tons in the 1860's to almost 300,000 tons by the mid-1870's. 15

The economic incentives supporting the rise of commercial fisheries were enormous, with fish becoming a critical item for both domestic consumption and international commerce. The fishing industry shaped Canada\'s economic environment, helping to expand coastal settlements, establish fishing ports, and develop trade networks. The demand for fish, propelled by an expanding population and a thriving worldwide market, pushed fishing methods from small-scale subsistence operations to large-scale commercial enterprises.16 As fishing operations increased, so did their influence on fish populations and ecosystems. The ecological repercussions of increased fishing and the depletion of specific fish species have been an increasing source of worry.17 Overfishing, motivated by a desire for profit and worsened by advances in fishing methods, resulted in losses in critical species, producing ecological imbalances. The transition from traditional Indigenous practices to European-style commercial fishing altered the connection between humans and the environment.

The shift from personal to commercial fishing was more than just about economics; it altered the socio-cultural dynamics of fishing communities and had ecological effects that echoed through the marine systems. The expansion of commercial fisheries became inextricably linked to Canada\'s economic prosperity, helping to expand coastal towns, establish fishing ports, and evolve trade networks. This can be seen clearer over the span of 50 years throughout fisheries along Niagara when examining total revenue made from commercial fishing in the year 1870 to the year 1920. In the province of Ontario during the year 1870 the annual revenue brought in reached a total of \$8, 547 dollars in comparison to the year 1920 which reached a total revenue collection of \$115, 301 dollars.18 Commercial fisheries have greatly impacted the economic success of Canada and the Niagara area by creating employment, bringing in export money, building infrastructure, and strengthening the nation\'s cultural legacy.

The increase in commercial fishing formed a turning point in the connection between humans and the aquatic environment. The demand for fish, fueled by financial benefits and a rising population, resulted in unprecedented abuse of marine resources. Advanced fishing technology, such as trawlers and longlines, have enabled commercial fleets to collect previously unthinkable amounts of fish.19 The effects of this exponential increase in fishing pressure were felt not just locally, but also throughout the world\'s linked marine systems. Overfishing, the practice of collecting fish at rates greater than their ability to reproduce, has arisen as a major concern in Niagara-on-the-Lake and elsewhere. This first became prevalent during the late 1860's when annual reports stated a shortage of different species of fish such as salmon and trout near normally populated areas such as the Niagara River. These concerns began to arise due to a steep increase in overfishing resulting in a population decline that was not able to recover fast enough naturally due to human interference and the rise of commercial fishing in the early 1870's. This led to the creation of the Fisheries Act, a federal legislation meant to manage and protect the resources necessary to sustain Canda's fisheries. Not only did the Fisheries Act protect many different species of marine life but it also aims to protect the habitat and natural environment those animals need in order to reproduce, grow, and thrive.20

The Niagara River\'s natural equilibrium was upset when particular fish species saw dramatic losses. Iconic species such as salmon, trout, and whitefish that previously thrived in the region have undergone major population declines.21 Such a loss had far-reaching consequences for the aquatic environment, impacting the quantity and distribution of other species and altering existing food webs. The ecological consequences of overfishing go beyond the immediate impact on target species. The overfishing of particular fish populations from the ecosystem caused imbalances, resulting in the expansion of some prey species and the collapse of others. The ecological damage caused by overfishing offers light on how changes in one species\' abundance can have unforeseen implications throughout the food chain. 22 Such modifications influenced the behavior of other marine creatures, even those not directly targeted by commercial fishing.

Furthermore, the decline of fish populations had significant socio-economic consequences, particularly for Indigenous groups that had historically relied on fish as a primary resource. The loss of traditional fisheries weakened these communities' cultural and economic roots. Recognition of the negative repercussions of overfishing triggered an important change in fisheries management. To combat overfishing, governments and international organizations started imposing conservation measures including quotas, size limitations, and seasonal closures. The government sought to find a compromise between fulfilling the economic needs of the fishing sector and protecting the long-term viability of fish populations.23 As the region dealt with the fallout from previous overfishing, conservation initiatives aimed to rehabilitate fish populations and restore the health of the Niagara River ecosystem. Stocking programs, habitat restoration projects, and the development of marine protected areas all become key components of comprehensive measures to ameliorate the effects of previous exploitation on the Niagara Region. 24 Finally, the study of the influence of commercial fishing on fish populations in Niagara-on-the-Lake provides a more detailed knowledge of the complex interactions between human activities and the environment. The historical background of overfishing serves as a cautionary tale, emphasizing the importance of adaptable and sustainable methods for fisheries management.

The current fishing community in Niagara-on-the-Lake is defined by a mix of technological improvements, regulatory frameworks, and a rising concern for environmental sustainability. Indigenous Peoples once-traditional practices have given way to a more diverse range of tactics, including cutting-edge technology like sonar and GPS devices to improve navigation and fish monitoring. The introduction of motorized boats and sophisticated equipment has substantially boosted the efficiency and size of modern fishing operations, allowing commercial and recreational fishers to explore bigger regions in quest of a wider variety of fish species.25 Unlike in the past, when fishing was largely used for food and ceremonial purposes, modern fishing in Niagara-on-the-Lake serves a wide range of functions. Commercial fisheries provide a substantial contribution to the local and regional economies by creating jobs and promoting economic development.26 At the same time, recreational fishing has grown in popularity, attracting fishermen from both local and far-flung areas. This shift in the aim of fishing reflects both shifting public views about the environment and the region\'s economic growth. The set of laws has changed significantly in response to ecological concerns raised by previous overfishing. Governments enforce tight conservation measures, catch limitations, and seasonal restrictions on modern fishing techniques. In the last 5 years Niagara River Remedial Advisory Committee has organized a Habitat Restoration Plan that plans to preserve fish populations and their habitats. Stakeholders work to maintain healthy fish stocks, protect biodiversity, and ensure the long-term profitability of the commercial and recreational fishing sectors by restoring ecosystems, enforcing rules, and encouraging sustainable practices.27 These initiatives supported the general health of the ecosystem, the enhancement of the water quality, and the financial stability of nearby communities that depend on fishing supplies. The ultimate objective was to guarantee that the fisheries in the Niagara region could continue to be numerous and productive for both the current and next generations. Such laws attempted to promote fish population sustainability while also maintaining the delicate balance of the aquatic ecosystem.28

Furthermore, a rising emphasis to encourage recreational fishermen to practice catch-and-release fishing, which helps to preserve fish species in the long run is present in the region. Cultural and social characteristics continue to exist in modern fishing but in different ways. Fishing competitions, festivals, and community activities themed around fishing are strong signs of local identity and involvement. These activities not only connect people to the region\'s past but also help to raise awareness about the significance of ethical and sustainable fishing techniques.29 Additionally, an examination of modern fishing activities in Niagara-on-the-Lake shows a complex landscape affected by technical innovation, government restrictions, and shifting cultural norms. Due to rising concerns about environmental sustainability and population loss around the Niagara Region fish species such as salmon and steelhead, the government of Canada has updated and reintroduced their laws and guidelines regarding the Fisheries Act in 2019 in order to sustain Niagara's fisheries for the future. Such changes include protection of all fish and fish habitat as opposed to the protection of only commercial or recreational fisheries, ability to regulate inshore fishing policies as opposed to no reference about inshore fisheries. And lastly an increased focus on habitat restoration and the rebuilding on fish stocks as opposed to no provisions to restore habitat or fish stocks listed in the original Fisheries Act.30

In conclusion, the history of fishing in Niagara-on-the-Lake gives an important narrative that connects early Indigenous People's traditions to the region\'s expanding fishing culture today. From our predecessors\' innovative methods, such as weirs and fish wheels, which demonstrate a profound ecological awareness, to European immigrants\' transformational influence on commercial fisheries, each historical era left a lasting mark on the local terrain. Through examining the economic, cultural, and ecological components, it details insights into humanity\'s complicated interaction with the aquatic environment. The shift from traditional Indigenous approaches to current practices provides a lens through which we may assess Niagara\'s impact on the lake\'s communities. It becomes clear that fishing, far from being an economic activity, demonstrates culture, the environment, and the growing history of an area strongly connected to its aquatic resources.


  1. Beaudoin, Alwynne B. "The Fisher Site" Canadian Journal of Archaeology / Journal Canadien d'Archéologie 26, no. 1 (2002): 66--72. 

  2. Niagara Region. "New Niagara Official Plan: Niagara Region Archaeological Management Plan:" (2021), 6. 

  3. William Jewell,  The Golden Cabinet of True Treasure (London: John Crosley, 1612; Ann Arbor: Text Creation Partnership, 2011): 100-102. 

  4. Jewell,  The Golden Cabinet of True Treasure, 103. 

  5. Erin Breen and Anna Metaxas. \"Predicting the interactions between \'ecologically equivalent\' indigenous and nonindigenous brachyurans.\" Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 69, no. 5 (2012): 

  6. Breen, "Predicting the interactions", 2012, 6. 

  7. Laurie LeClair. "The Secrets of the Mnjikaning Fish Weirs." MUSKRAT Magazine, September 11, 2017. 

  8. Beaudoin, "The Fisher Site". 2002, 64. 

  9. Peter Edwards." Wake-Up Call: The Environmental and Human Health Implications of Bio transported PCBs in the Subarctic of North America." Lunds University, 2002, 29. 

  10. Charles R. Menzies and Caroline F. Butler. "Returning to Selective Fishing through Indigenous Fisheries Knowledge: The Example of K'moda, Gitxaała Territory." American Indian Quarterly 31, no. 3 (2007): 2-7. 

  11. Menzies, Returning to Selective Fishing through Indigenous Fisheries Knowledge, 6. 

  12. Jewell,  The Golden Cabinet of True Treasure, 101. 

  13. Jewell,  The Golden Cabinet of True Treasure, 101. 

  14. Michael J. Bradford, Keith D. Clarke, Marten A. Koops, et al. "The Science Framework for Implementing the Fisheries Protection Provisions of Canada's Fisheries Act." Fisheries 40, no. 6 (June 2015): 268--75 

  15. William H.Lear \"History of fisheries in the Northwest Atlantic: the 500-year perspective.\" Journal of Northwest Atlantic Fishery Science 23 (1998). 55-56 

  16. Dominion of Canada. "Annual Report of the Fisheries Branch." no.63 (1868) 17-30. 

  17. Anthony T. Charles, "Fisheries Management in Atlantic Canada." Coastal Management 35, no. 2--3 (January 1997): 101--19. 

  18. Niagara Region. "New Niagara Official Plan: Niagara Region Archaeological Management Plan:" (1927-1928): 243 

  19. Steven J. Cooke, Karen M. Dunmall, L. Scott Forbes et al. \"A brief history of fisheries in Canada.\" Fisheries 45, no. 6 (2020): 303-318. 

  20. "Environment and Climate Change" Government of Canada, December 15, 2023. 

  21. John R. Michael Sullivan, Sean Cox, Nigel P. Lester, Carl J. Walters, Eric A. Parkinson, Andrew J. Paul, Leyland Jackson, and Brian J. Shuter. \"Canada\'s recreational fisheries: the invisible collapse?\" Fisheries 27, no. 1 (2002): 6-17. 

  22. Ray Hilborn, Carryn L. de Moor, et al. "Effective Fisheries Management Instrumental in Improving Fish Stock Status." Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 117, no. 4 (2020): 2218--24 

  23. Beaudoin, "The Fisher Site". 2002, 72. 

  24. Hilborn. "Effective Fisheries Management Instrumental in Improving Fish Stock Status", 2020, 8. 

  25. Stephen J. Walsh, Richard Ferro, Ronald Fonteyne. \"To catch or conserve more fish: the evolution of fishing technology in fisheries science.\" (2002), 14. 

  26. Donald A. McCrimmon Jr., "Sustainable Fisheries Management in the Great Lakes: Scientific and Operational Challenges." Lakes & Reservoirs : Research and Management 7, no. 3 (2002): 241--54. 

  27. Niagara Peninsula Conservation, "Bi-National Habitat Restoration," Niagara River Remedial Action Plan, accessed April 2, 2024. 

  28. Dominion of Canada. "Annual Report of the Fisheries Branch." no.63 (1928) 17-30. 

  29. Stig S. Gezelius, \"The Social Aspects of Fishing Effort: Technology and Community in Norway\'s Blue Whiting Fisheries.\" Human Ecology 35, no. 5 (10, 2007): 587-599. 

  30. Government of Canada. "Introducing Canada's modernized Fisheries Act", 2021.